The first, called Vicky (get it?), is said to be that of an actress who disappeared after returning to her dressing room to retrieve a fan. Now she roams the theater, her appearance signalled by the scent of her perfume and the sound of her dress rustling. The rustling was even heard by WDTN Channel 2 in Dayton during their 1990 Halloween special. She is occasionally seen by theater employees but tends to be skittish.

The other ghost is that of Lucille, who was assaulted in the privacy box at house left--the left as you face the stage. She survived the assault and lived to be an old woman, but it's said that if you visit the old box you will feel the anguish Lucille felt during her attack. One visitor was even slapped.

The third ghost is one whose face was seen on the curtains backstage before they were replaced with doors. He is supposed to be that of a suicide who impaled himself on a knife fastened to the back of a seat.