Old Chestnut Grove Cemetery
Cleveland's Old Chestnut Grove Cemetery is the site of multiple hauntings. The grave of a witch is located there, next to a big, old tree, marked only by a fence which surrounds the place where there should be a gravestone. The ground is sunken in above where she's buried. It's said that if you get too close to her grave, "something terrible" will happen to you.
In addition, the back of the cemetery, where the older markers are located along the Rocky River, is haunted by mysterious lights late at night.